Will or Revocable Trust? A Practical Comparison for Long Island Homeowners

Last reviewed: November 20, 2026

By Jordan M. Endler, Esq.
Attorney Advertising

There is no prize for picking the "advanced" option. A simple will is the right plan for many people, and a revocable living trust is the right plan for others. The useful question is which one fits your house, your family and your tolerance for paperwork.

The short version

Will Revocable living trust
Takes effect At death When signed and funded
Covers Property in your own name at death Only property titled to the trust
Court involvement at death Usually yes, in Surrogate's Court Usually less, for trust property
Privacy Becomes a court record once filed Generally stays private
If you become ill Does nothing Successor trustee can manage trust property
Medicaid protection None None
Setup effort Lower Higher: deeds and accounts must be retitled
Can you change it? Yes, until death Yes, while you have capacity

How each one is signed in New York

A will must be signed at the end by the person making it, in front of at least two witnesses (or acknowledged to them). The person must tell the witnesses that the document is their will. Both witnesses sign within a 30-day period and give their addresses. Most attorneys supervise this "will ceremony" to make sure every step happens. (New York has passed a law allowing electronic wills that is scheduled to take effect on December 12, 2027. Until then, plan on paper.)

A revocable trust must be in writing and either acknowledged before a notary like a deed or signed in front of two witnesses who also sign. The same formality applies when you amend or revoke it later.

The step people forget: funding the trust

A trust controls only what it owns. After the trust is signed:

  • The house needs a new deed to you as trustee, recorded with the county clerk
  • Bank and brokerage accounts are retitled to the trust, or given a beneficiary designation that names it
  • Retirement accounts and life insurance usually stay in your name, with beneficiaries reviewed

Anything left outside the trust still passes under your will. That is why people with trusts also sign a short "pour-over" will.

What happens at death

With a will, your executor generally must have the will admitted to probate in the Surrogate's Court for the county where you lived before taking charge of assets in your sole name. With a fully funded revocable trust, the successor trustee can usually manage and distribute trust property without that step. For a Long Island family whose main asset is a house, that can save time.

Either way, some assets pass outside both documents: jointly owned property, accounts with "payable on death" or "transfer on death" designations, retirement accounts, and life insurance go to the named person or co-owner.

What happens if you become ill

A will does nothing while you are alive. If you have a revocable trust and become unable to manage things, your successor trustee can step in for trust property. For property outside the trust, you need a durable power of attorney. Either way, you also want a health care proxy.

What a revocable trust does not do

  • It does not protect assets for Medicaid. Because you can revoke it, Medicaid treats everything in it as yours. Medicaid planning uses a different tool, the irrevocable trust.
  • It does not reduce income tax while you are alive.
  • It does not stop a challenge. A trust can be contested, just as a will can.

A quick self-check

A will may be enough if your estate is simple, you are comfortable with a court process for the estate, and your beneficiaries are adults who get along.

A revocable trust may be worth the extra setup if you want privacy, own property in more than one state, have a beneficiary who will need money managed over time, or want a smooth handoff if you become ill.

Talk to the office

To decide which plan fits, call Jordan M. Endler, P.C. at (631) 896-2211 or email Endlerlaw@gmail.com. The firm's website is www.jmeesq.com.


Sources

  • N.Y. EPTL § 3-2.1 (execution and attestation of wills; electronic wills effective December 12, 2027): https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/EPT/3-2.1
  • N.Y. EPTL § 7-1.17 (execution, amendment and revocation of lifetime trusts): https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/EPT/7-1.17
  • N.Y. Social Services Law § 366(2)(b)(2)(i) (revocable trusts treated as available to the creator): https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/SOS/366
  • NYS Unified Court System, Suffolk County Surrogate's Court: https://www.nycourts.gov/courts/suffolk-county-surrogates-court-0
  • NYS Unified Court System, Nassau County Surrogate's Court: https://www.nycourts.gov/courts/10th-jd-nassau/nassau-county-surrogates-court